Definition of Problem Solving in Business Proposals
When we send a business proposal, what are we doing? A prospect or customer, has a need or a problem and they are seeking a solution from an external source. They require a supplier, provider, consultant or contractor to understand their problem and propose a perfectly aligned offer and solution. Yes, proposals will be compared against other bidders, but typically the proposal which best solves the problem, with a reasonable price, will win! Ensuring you can write the very best 'problem solving proposal' is then key!
Of course, problem solving is a vital business skill that helps you tackle challenges. It involves identifying issues, analysing them, and creating effective plans to resolve them.
Types of Problems
Problems come in various forms. Simple problems have clear solutions, like fixing a flat tyre or supplying a business with office supplies. Here the solution, added value and customer service, for example is still important, but there is where price can be the deciding factor, unless it also happens to be a key requirement or high risk if it goes wrong. Complex problems involve multiple factors and require more thought. For example, improving a company's sales process. Ill-defined problems are tricky because they're unclear. Think of trying to boost team morale without knowing the root cause of low spirits.
Some problems are technical, needing specific knowledge or skills. Others are people-related, involving communication or conflicts. You might face short-term problems that need quick fixes, or long-term issues that require ongoing efforts.
Stages in Problem Solving
The problem-solving process typically follows a set of stages. First, you identify the issue at hand. This means spotting what's wrong and why it matters. Next, you gather information about the problem. Look at facts, ask questions, and collect data.
After that, you brainstorm possible solutions. Think creatively and consider different approaches. Then, you evaluate these options. Weigh their pros and cons to pick the best one. Once you've chosen a solution, it's time to put it into action. Create a plan and carry it out step by step. This is an exercise which will be carried out by the customer prior to going out to tender in order for them to share their requirements. However, once you receive this information it is important you use your specialist expertise in the market and industry to add more value with your problem solving proposal.
Problem Solving Methodologies
Problem solving methodologies help you tackle challenges systematically. They give you tools to break down complex issues and find effective solutions.
Analytical Approach
The analytical approach involves breaking problems into smaller parts. You start by gathering data and facts about the issue. Then you analyse this information to spot patterns or trends. With a detail tender pack and specification, you can often use each requirement as a base to assess how you can exceed it when forming your solution.
Try using the A3 problem solving method. It's a step-by-step process that fits on a single A3-sized paper. You identify the problem, analyse its root causes, and propose solutions.
Another useful tool is the fishbone diagram. It helps you see all possible causes of a problem. You list main categories of causes, then add specific factors under each.
| Step | Description |
|---|---|
| 1. Identify the Problem | Clearly define the problem or effect you want to analyse. This is the "head" of the fish. |
| 2. Brainstorm Major Categories | Identify the main categories of potential causes. Common categories include People, Methods, Materials, Machines, Environment, and Measurements. |
| 3. Draw the Backbone and Fishbones | Start with a horizontal arrow pointing to the problem statement, then draw diagonal lines (fishbones) for each category leading to the backbone. |
| 4. List Possible Causes | Under each category, brainstorm possible causes related to that category. These are written as branches off the main bones. |
| 5. Investigate Root Causes | Discuss and analyse each potential cause to identify which are contributing factors to the problem. Add further branches to these root causes if needed. |
| 6. Review and Prioritise | Evaluate all identified causes, prioritising those that need immediate attention or further investigation. |
| 7. Take Action | Develop a plan to address the key root causes identified in the diagram, focusing on eliminating or mitigating the major contributors to the problem. |
Creative Approach
Creative problem solving encourages thinking outside the box. It's useful when you need fresh ideas or when standard methods aren't working. For example, you proposal win rates are not good enough. Your problem solving proposal is not convincing enough nor resinating with the reader. It's time to look at the sector, your competition, the overall requirements - and think - is there a better way for us tackle this market? This will be tailored for each proposal and as you work with your customers and engage with them, it can be developed each time.
Try brainstorming sessions is what we work do with our new bid writing consultancy clients.
Logical Reasoning
Logical reasoning uses structured thinking to solve problems. It's great for complex issues that need a clear, step-by-step approach.
The five whys technique can help you find root causes. Ask "why" five times to dig deeper into an issue. Each answer becomes the basis for the next question.
Decision trees are useful for weighing options. You map out possible choices and their outcomes. This helps you see the best path forward based on likely results.
You may use a mix of this problem solving techniques when developing your proposals, but the key is that you really are trying to find the perfect solution.
Looking for proposal writing training?
Contact us todayFormulating Solutions
Coming up with effective solutions is key to problem-solving. You'll need to think creatively, manage risks, and plan for different scenarios.
Innovative Solutions
Think outside the box when brainstorming ideas. Use techniques like mind mapping or reverse thinking to spark creativity. Don't dismiss wild ideas right away - they might lead to breakthrough solutions.
Ask "what if" questions to challenge assumptions. For example, "What if we did the opposite of what we normally do?"
Look at how other industries solve similar problems. You might find new approaches that can be adapted to your situation.
Get input from diverse team members. Different viewpoints can uncover solutions you hadn't considered.
Risk Management
Identify potential risks for each solution you come up with. Make a list of what could go wrong.
Rate each risk based on how likely it is to happen and how big the impact would be. Focus on the high-impact, high-likelihood risks first.
Come up with ways to reduce or avoid each risk. This might include backup plans or extra safety measures.
Do a cost-benefit analysis. Compare the potential gains of a solution against its risks and costs.
Contingency Planning
Create "if-then" plans for different scenarios. What will you do if your first solution doesn't work?
Set up trigger points that will prompt you to switch to a backup plan. This helps you act quickly if things go wrong.
Make sure you have the resources needed for your backup plans. This might include extra staff, supplies, or funding.
Test your contingency plans if possible. Run drills or simulations to spot any weak points before a real crisis hits.
Keep your plans up to date. Review and revise them regularly as your situation changes.
Stakeholder Analysis in Problem Solving Proposals
Stakeholder analysis is a critical step when developing problem-solving proposals. It helps you understand who is affected by the problem and their roles and interests in addressing it. By identifying and prioritising stakeholders, you can strategically approach working with them based on their roles, interests and influences.Start by listing all individuals and groups who may impact or be impacted by your project, both in the evaluation and delivery stages. Assess each stakeholder's level of power and interest, then map them on a matrix. This visual representation allows you to easily identify key players who require the most attention and engagement in your proposal.
Remember, effective stakeholder management can significantly influence the outcome of your bid. By proactively analysing and engaging stakeholders, you can align their interests, manage expectations, and ultimately increase the likelihood of your proposal's success.
Problem Solving Proposal: Council Stakeholder Example
When bidding for a contract with a local council, for example, you can conduct a thorough stakeholder analysis to identify all parties who may be impacted by or have an interest in the project. This ensures your proposal effectively addresses their challenges and demonstrates your understanding of the wider context.
Key stakeholders in a local council bidding context may include:
- The Council itself, including relevant departments such as procurement, finance, and the specific department responsible for the service area
- Local Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) and NHS Trust, if the contract involves health and social care services
- The police, if the contract relates to community safety or crime reduction initiatives
- The current supplier of the service, as they may be impacted by the transition process or have valuable insights
- Local residents, community groups, and residents associations, as they are likely to be the end-users or beneficiaries of the service
By identifying these stakeholders and considering their position and requirements from the tender, you can really shape your problem solving proposal to make an impact.
A successful bid not only shows your technical expertise but also exhibits your ability to understand and manage complex stakeholder relationships. By conducting a stakeholder analysis and tailoring your proposal accordingly, you can differentiate yourself from competitors and increase your chances of winning the contract.
Implementation Plan
An effective implementation plan guides your project to success. It outlines key steps, resources, and metrics to track progress. By this time you will have fully broken down the requirement, created your solution and therefore you will have a framework to build a detailed implementation plan, which forms a key part of your problem solving proposal.
Timelines
Start by setting clear timelines for each phase of your project. Break down larger goals into smaller, manageable tasks. Assign start and end dates to each task. Use a Gantt chart to visualise your timeline and even within formal and highly restricted tenders, you often are able to supply this as an additional document, which means it's a real chance to give reassurance of your knowledge and ability. Get really stuck into the detail - step by step, what will happen once you are awarded the contract.
Resource Allocation
Identify the resources you'll need for each task. This includes people, materials, and budget. Make a list of team members and their roles:
- Project Manager: Oversees the entire project
- Designer: Creates visual elements
- Developer: Builds the solution
- Tester: Checks for quality and bugs
Estimate the costs for each resource. Create a budget that covers all expenses, including software, equipment, and training. Track spending throughout the project to stay on budget.
Milestones and Metrics
Set clear milestones to mark important points in your project. These help you track progress and celebrate achievements. Some key milestones might be:
- Completing the design phase
- Finishing the first working prototype
- Passing all quality tests
Choose metrics to measure success. These could include:
- Number of tasks completed on time
- Percentage of budget used
- User satisfaction scores
Use a simple tracking system to monitor these metrics. Regular check-ins with your team will help you stay on top of progress and quickly address any issues that arise.
Being highly practical and pragmatic is the key. Each step you provide shows reassurance of your knowledge.
You may also find the following useful for examples:
